When an employee has a hospital stay, the bill behind it can look impossible to decode. A $45,000 price tag and a statement full of codes don't make it easy to see what you're paying for or where you could pay less.
The good news is that hospital billing follows a logic, and once you see it, you can ask better questions, help employees spend smarter, and even build a working relationship with the hospitals in your market.
That is why Amanda Brummitt sat down with Dr. Kevin Stevenson on the Generous Benefits Podcast. Kevin a healthcare executive who has led strategic operations in multiple health systems, and his hospital career spans several states and includes CEO and COO roles. Amanda comes from hospital administration too, and she wanted his help showing employers what is behind the bill so they can ask better questions and build stronger partnerships with their local hospitals.
Kevin says the list price on a hospital bill is a lot like the sticker on a car. Hospitals base every bill on a charge master, which is simply the hospital's list of prices. Kevin says those list prices typically run three to five times what anyone actually pays. Insurers use them only as a starting point for negotiation.
What matters is the allowed amount, the plan payment, and the patient's share. Kevin walks through a simple example. A hip replacement lists at $45,000. The insurer has negotiated a $38,000 discount, so the allowed amount is $7,000. On an 80/20 plan, the insurer pays $5,600 and the employee owes $1,400 in coinsurance. That last number is the one your employee feels, and the allowed amount is the one your plan should watch.
Hospitals now post their prices online in two forms: machine readable files with payer-specific rates, and shoppable service estimates for consumers. Kevin's advice is not to read every line. Pick one or two procedures that matter to your plan, look up their CPT codes, and compare them across the hospitals in your area. Kevin says even hospitals across the street from each other can vary by 300 to 400 percent.
A higher price doesn't automatically mean higher quality. Kevin describes a surgeon who scheduled knee replacements in batches, educated patients beforehand, let his team work at the top of their licenses, and had patients rehab together. That model drove prices down and kept quality high.
On reference-based pricing, Kevin sees potential savings over a traditional PPO and more transparency. The tradeoffs are that some providers refuse it, patients can face balance billing, and the plan needs more administration, solid stop loss coverage, and strong patient advocacy.
The bill is final. It usually isn't, especially for self-pay patients. Kevin says if you get a $1,000 list price bill, calling the hospital and offering to pay $400 today is often welcome, because the hospital may only collect a fraction of the list price anyway.
In network means affordable. In network only means your insurer negotiated a rate. For a high dollar procedure like a knee or hip replacement, Kevin says it's worth shopping, and an out of network option is sometimes cheaper.
Emergency bills can't be challenged. Kevin notes that the No Surprises Act protects patients from most surprise billing and requires out of network emergency care to be billed at in-network rates. Amanda adds a practical step: if you chose an in-network facility and got a bill from an out of network physician group, call that group first, then call hospital administration. Kevin agrees that administrators want to fix those problems.
Billing codes are accurate. Kevin estimates that about 80 percent of bills contain mistakes. He's clear that it isn't hospitals trying to take advantage of anyone. Busy nurses document late, and a coder may read a note differently. Review bills closely.
An unpaid bill will wreck your credit. Kevin explains that medical debt under $500 is no longer reported, and paid medical debt is removed. He isn't telling anyone to skip a bill, but payment plans are common and charity care is available at not-for-profit hospitals.
Kevin recommends starting with your own data. Identify your five to ten highest cost procedures by volume, compare what you pay with market rates, and find two or three high quality, cost effective hospitals nearby. Start with one, then talk with the others. He points to Walmart, which negotiated prices with a few top hospitals and pays employees' travel for procedures like knee replacements because it costs less overall.
On your side of the table, bring your CFO or benefits lead, a broker or consultant with direct contracting experience who speaks healthcare's language, and legal counsel. On the hospital side, ask for contracting and network development, someone who can speak to quality (infection rates, return to work data), and a revenue cycle person who can explain how claims will be handled. Amanda adds that if your broker resists the idea of these conversations, treat it as a red flag.
Teach employees what to ask before a planned procedure. What's the CPT code? What's the contracted rate with my insurance? What will I owe after my deductible? Does the estimate include the facility fee and the physician fees? Amanda also reminds listeners that site of service matters, since a hospital is the right place for a heart issue but not for an ear infection.
For quality, Kevin points to the CMS star ratings on the Medicare website, which cover mortality, readmissions, patient experience and safety. Leapfrog grades hospitals A to F on safety twice a year. He considers both more data driven than magazine rankings, since hospitals have to pay to use those ranking badges. For pricing and peer support, he mentions FAIR Health's consumer cost estimator and employer coalitions such as the Purchaser Business Group on Health.
Hospitals aren't the enemy, and they're often more open to a conversation than employers expect. Start with your own claims data, choose partners on quality and not just price, use posted prices to compare, and give your employees the questions and tools to make good decisions. Better decisions by employees can mean lower costs for everyone.
Hear Kevin Stevenson, a former hospital CEO and COO, explain how hospital billing really works on the Generous Benefits Podcast: https://generousbenefits.podbean.com/e/understanding-hospital-billing/