Skip to content
Benefits Compliance
Bret Brummitt11/2/26, 3:29 PM7 min read

Benefits Compliance Mistakes That Put Employers on the DOL's Radar

Most employers don't think about their benefit plan documents until someone asks for them. A participant wants a copy, a letter arrives from the Department of Labor, or a buyer's attorneys start due diligence. At that point, the gaps in how your health and retirement plans have been run get very visible, very fast.

Most of these mistakes are ordinary ones that come from good intentions and paperwork that never caught up with the plan. Here are five that ERISA attorney Lori Oliphant sees trip employers up, and what to do about each.

Mistake 1: Missing or Inconsistent Plan Documents

Employer-sponsored plans are governed by ERISA and the Internal Revenue Code, and ERISA requires your benefit plans to be written down in a plan document. Lori Oliphant, managing member of Steptoe & Johnson's Dallas office and an employee benefits and ERISA attorney, puts it simply: the document spells out the promises, the responsibilities and the conditions and limitations, so everyone knows what will and won't happen.

Lori points to three moments when the formal documents suddenly matter. A participant can request plan documents, and she notes you have 30 days to provide them, with penalties of $100 a day if you don't. A Department of Labor inquiry will list the plan document first on its request. And in a sale, the buyer's due diligence team will ask for everything, and missing paperwork makes them wonder what else isn't in order.

Documents that don't match each other cause the same trouble. Lori says it only takes one disgruntled participant, possibly with an attorney, to request everything and find the inconsistencies.

What About ERISA Wrap Documents?

Many employers lean on a wrap plan document to cover their ERISA obligations. Lori describes a wrap as an umbrella: one basket that holds all of your welfare plan programs, with the ERISA-required language added in case the insurance policies underneath don't say what they need to say.

The weak spot is that the insurer administers its policy according to the policy, not according to your wrap. Some wrap documents are bare-minimum versions produced by compliance tools that technically check the box but say very little, while the plan is still run on the actual carrier documents. When the wrap and the policies don't line up, Lori says it works until it doesn't. It only takes one participant asking for every document to expose the conflict.

If you use a wrap, Lori suggests a few safeguards:

  • Write the wrap so its provisions apply only when the insurance policy is silent or doesn't comply with ERISA.
  • Still review the claims procedures in each insurance policy to make sure they are compliant, even where they differ from the wrap.
  • Where a carrier's policy falls short, add an addendum with compliant claims procedures, since ERISA requires you to give participants a summary plan description that includes them.

Wraps do serve real purposes. Lori explains that they are often there for the Form 5500. Welfare plans with more than 100 participants file an annual report, and a wrap helps show that medical, dental and other coverages are a single plan so the employer can file one Form 5500 instead of several. She doesn't think a wrap is strictly required to do that, but it helps. A wrap can also close the loop on non-compliant provisions in vendors' documents and show the Department of Labor that you were trying to comply.

Even so, Lori's view is that the best practice is to get all of your plan documents in order so you aren't relying on a wrap to cover the gaps.

Mistake 2: Making Exceptions on Claims Without a Record

This one shows up most in self-funded medical plans. Your third-party administrator reads the plan document and denies a claim. The participant appeals, and that appeal often lands with the employer. Now you have to decide whether to uphold the denial or overturn it.

Lori cautions employers to be very careful about overturning a decision that matches the plan document. Similarly situated participants have to be treated the same way. If you make an exception, she advises recording in the meeting minutes exactly what was decided and why, down to the detail that would distinguish it from a future case.

There's also a financial risk. Most smaller self-funded employers carry stop-loss insurance for large claims, and that policy was issued based on the terms of your plan. If you change those terms by exception, Lori warns, the stop-loss carrier may refuse to reimburse you. Her advice is to call the stop-loss carrier before you make the change so everyone knows where they stand.

Some requests come from a soft spot, such as wanting better coverage for newborns. Others come from highly compensated executives who feel they've earned better coverage. Even then, Lori says, if you make the exception, be prepared to make it for everybody.

Mistake 3: Getting Loose With Eligibility

Bret Brummitt, principal at Generous Benefits, hears a familiar version of this often. A leader hires someone and promises coverage on a start date the plan doesn't allow. Lori sees bigger versions, especially in smaller and family-owned companies: putting adult children, parents or other relatives on the plan as "employees" when they don't actually work there.

Some employers have been told the insurance company never checks. Bret says that's true in some cases, but in others carriers do compare against payroll and tax records, and a large claim is exactly what prompts a closer look. Lori points out that if someone who has never provided services has a catastrophic claim, the carrier may call to ask about that employee.

Covering people outside your employer group can also turn your plan into a multiple employer welfare arrangement, or MEWA. Lori explains that a self-funded plan is generally not subject to state insurance laws, but a self-funded MEWA can be, which can mean reserves, filings and state-mandated benefits.

Mistake 4: Ignoring Nondiscrimination Rules

For self-funded health plans, Lori explains that you can't give highly compensated employees and their dependents better eligibility terms or benefits than everyone else. The same concept applies to retirement plans, where giving executives a richer profit sharing contribution than other employees generally won't pass without meeting additional tests.

The consequences are serious. Lori says a retirement plan that fails can be disqualified, making all the benefits taxable. In a self-funded health plan, the benefits paid to highly compensated individuals can become taxable. That's the benefits, not the premiums, so a large procedure could become taxable income.

Lori also flags a common setup that she says calls for a conversation with counsel right away: putting management in one entity with one health plan and everyone else in another entity with a different plan. Unless those plans are fully insured, that's likely to raise nondiscrimination issues, and the cafeteria plan used for pre-tax premiums has its own rules too.

Mistake 5: Assuming Your Entities Aren't Related

Whether two companies count as a single employer affects eligibility, MEWA status and nondiscrimination testing. Lori says this question comes to her weekly.

A controlled group is the more mathematical test. It starts at 80 percent ownership, which is different from the 50 percent threshold some accountants use for other purposes. Parent and subsidiary groups are the simplest case. Brother-sister groups start with whether five or fewer people own 80 percent or more of two companies, and then a second test looks at whether their overlapping ownership reaches at least 50 percent. These often come up with spouses, family members and friends who invest together.

Affiliated service groups are harder. Lori says they depend on facts and circumstances with very little guidance. A doctor or lawyer whose professional association owns a small stake in a practice may not be in a controlled group but can still be in an affiliated service group.

The Bottom Line

Lori's advice for employers trying to save money and do right by employees is practical. Set aside time each year to review your plan documents. Keep notes during the year on anything that didn't go the way you wanted, then formally update the documents rather than just administering the plan the way you'd prefer.

Most of all, be an active fiduciary for your health plan as well as your retirement plan. Ask your broker and consultants questions in email and get their answers in email. If the Department of Labor ever comes calling, Lori says that record shows you were trying to do the right thing. And when you're unsure, call your attorney before you act.

This article is for education only and is not legal advice.

Want to go deeper?

Hear ERISA attorney Lori Oliphant explain the compliance missteps that trip employers up on the Generous Benefits Podcast: https://generousbenefits.podbean.com/e/benefits-practices-that-reduce-regulator-scrutiny/

 

avatar
Bret Brummitt
In 2019, Bret launched Generous Benefits, leveraging 20 years of experience in Employee Benefits. His mission is to transform communities through innovative benefits solutions. Bret envisions benefits beyond traditional offerings, aiming for a lasting impact by stretching, tailoring, and curating packages. He coaches insurance agencies with Q4intelligence, actively participating in communities like Health Rosetta and the Free Market Medical Association. Based in Austin, he balances his professional pursuits with running alongside Gilbert's Gazelles and playing baseball with the Austin Blue Jays.

Related Articles